Screened vs. Unscreened Pools: What Englewood Homeowners Should Know
By Judson, owner of Manasota Pool Service | Last updated November 2026
Quick answer: A screened pool (inside a pool cage or lanai enclosure) stays cleaner, keeps out bugs and most leaves, and loses chlorine to sunlight a bit more slowly, so it's usually cheaper to maintain. An unscreened pool offers open views and more sun but collects more debris, needs more frequent cleaning, and typically costs more for weekly service. Most pools in Englewood and Venice are screened.
Why are so many Florida pools screened?
Pool enclosures are common in Southwest Florida because they keep out mosquitoes, no-see-ums, leaves, palm fronds and wildlife, and they add a layer of shade. They also make the pool area more usable during buggy months.
What are the benefits of a screened pool?
- Less debris: far fewer leaves, palm litter and sand in the water.
- Fewer bugs: mosquitoes and no-see-ums stay outside.
- Lower maintenance: less skimming and vacuuming each week.
- Some shade: screens filter a portion of sunlight, which helps chlorine last a little longer.
- Wildlife barrier: helps keep out frogs, toads, lizards, snakes and birds, though not perfectly.
What are the downsides of a screened pool?
- Screens tear and need repair or rescreening over time.
- Storm damage: high winds can damage screens and frames during hurricanes.
- Upkeep of the enclosure: frames and screens get dirty and may need cleaning.
- Less direct sun: pools stay slightly cooler, which some swimmers notice in winter.
What are the benefits of an unscreened pool?
- Open views of the yard, water or sky.
- More sun and warmth, which can warm the water.
- No enclosure repairs or rescreening costs.
What are the downsides of an unscreened pool?
- More debris: leaves, palm fronds, pollen and sand blow straight in.
- More bugs and wildlife in and around the pool.
- Faster chlorine loss from direct sunlight.
- Higher maintenance cost: more time each visit and more chemicals.
Does a screened pool cost less to maintain?
Usually, yes. Screened pools take less time to clean each week and use fewer chemicals, so pool service is often less expensive. Many local companies charge about $20 or more extra per month for unscreened pools. See our pool service pricing guide for local ranges.
Do screened pools still get dirty?
Yes. Rain still gets in, fine dust and pollen pass through screens, and small debris collects on the floor. Screened pools still need weekly testing, brushing and vacuuming, especially during the rainy season.
What should you check after a storm?
After strong winds, check your enclosure for torn screens, bent frames or loose panels before using the pool. For unscreened pools, expect heavy debris and plan for a thorough cleanup. See What to Do With Your Pool After a Hurricane.
Pool service for screened and unscreened pools in Englewood and South Venice
Manasota Pool Service cleans screened and unscreened pools throughout Englewood, Manasota Key and South Venice. Every visit includes a photo report, so you'll know your pool was cleaned and we'll mention anything we notice, like a torn screen. You'll have the same technician at the same time every week.
Get a free quote or see our plans.
Frequently asked questions
Is a screened pool easier to maintain?
Yes. Screens keep out most leaves, bugs and debris, so screened pools need less cleaning and fewer chemicals.
Does pool service cost more for an unscreened pool?
Usually. Many local companies charge about $20 or more extra per month because unscreened pools take longer to clean.
Do screened pools still need weekly service?
Yes. Rain, pollen and fine debris still get in, and water chemistry still needs regular testing.
Do pool screens reduce sunlight on the pool?
Somewhat. Screens filter part of the sunlight, which can help chlorine last a little longer and keep water slightly cooler.
Can hurricanes damage pool enclosures?
Yes. High winds can tear screens and bend frames. Check your enclosure after any major storm.